The Mercedes-AMG C 43 takes on its fiercest competitor, the BMW M340i, in a race round India’s latest observe.
Sports activities sedans are on a regular basis drivers however ones that additionally inject a great dose of adrenaline into your every day commute, and what we’ve right here with us are two German sedans that do precisely that – the Mercedes-AMG C 43 and the BMW M340i. So which one’s higher? With entry to the CoASTT race observe and India’s first Formulation 1 driver, Narain Karthikeyan, slightly than evaluate these two ont inheritor every day benefit, we determined to spice issues up and do issues otherwise. So we sized them up primarily based on their sporty credentials as a substitute.
Mercedes-AMG C 43 vs BMW M340i: powertrains
Beneath the C 43’s monumental bonnet is an AMG-developed 2.0-litre turbo-petrol engine codenamed M139l, which Mercedes says has F1-derived applied sciences to eradicate turbo lag and improve responsiveness. This four-cylinder unit belts out a potent 408hp and 500Nm of torque, giving it a 34hp benefit over the M340i, which packs in a bigger 3.0-litre six-cylinder turbo-petrol producing 374hp and an an identical 500Nm of torque.
Each automobiles get rear-biased all-wheel-drive programs, however the C 43’s rear-axle steering provides a larger diploma of agility into the combo. This tech, nevertheless, comes with a weight penalty, making the C 43 round 60 kilos heavier than the BMW; this swings the torque-to-weight ratio within the latter’s favour.
However the proof is within the pudding, so we lined these two automobiles up for a drag race to start with. Of their most ‘Sport Plus’ drive mode setting, with traction management partially off and launch controls engaged, it was the BMW’s sonorous six-cylinder melody that drowned the AMG’s muted purr. What adopted although was a revelation. Throughout the first few metres, it was Mercedes’ F1-derived know-how that got here into play. The electrical motor spooled the turbocharger even earlier than the exhaust gases gushed in. Because of this, the C 43 leapt off the road with larger ferocity and bought a headstart. Nevertheless, as soon as the BMW’s six-cylinder bought on tune, the M340i sailed previous the Mercedes, and crossed the end line first. In case you’d take a look at their claimed 0-100kph acceleration instances, they’re inside 0.2 seconds of one another (BMW’s being 4.4 seconds and Mercedes’ being 4.6 seconds), nevertheless, what’s clear is how effortlessly the M340i overtook the C 43 on account of the three.0’s sheer muscle and stronger top-end.
The C 43 is sort of a scalpel, whereas the M340i is sort of a sledgehammer.
In rolling races, from 30kph and 50kph, the place off-the-line responses are taken out of the equation, the variations of their efficiency have been way more pronounced. Working as a catalyst was BMW’s 8-speed torque converter, which was a lot faster to react and downshifted ahead of the AMG’s dual-clutch 9-speeder. Mix that with the BMW’s sheer grunt, the AMG had no likelihood to make up for misplaced floor.
Mercedes-AMG C 43 vs BMW M340i: observe timings
After our straight line acceleration exams, it was time so as to add corners into the combo. And to maintain issues stage, we hand these automobiles over to Kartikeyan, to unleash their full potential across the 3.8km CoASTT race observe. With the automobiles of their sportiest setting and all driver aids turned off, it was time for motion.
Kartikeyan bought into the M340i first, and he instantly learnt about its very un- BMW-like character. Not like BMWs of yore that swung their tail out at each given alternative, the M340i’s all-wheel drive made it understeer a good bit and he discovered the general setup on the softer aspect. Narain talked about that “the load of the automobile exhibits up on the observe”, significantly whereas cornering and altering instructions, and felt “a bit difficult”. He additionally mentioned he’d desire higher, extra confidence-inspiring brakes. Nevertheless, what impressed him essentially the most was its stonking turbo-petrol engine: “It is rather quick in a straight line”. The BMW’s bigger capability engine felt way more easy when pushed at its limits, and felt prefer it had extra energy in reserve.
“BMW’s B58 is a stonking engine, nevertheless, you’ll be able to really feel the automobile’s weight on a race observe.”
Subsequent, Kartikeyan took the C 43 to set a lap time and commented that the AMG was “a driver-focused automobile” with its sharper front-end and a comparatively firmer setup, which made it the extra track-biased of the 2. The C 43’s 2.0-litre engine served efficiency in a robust and linear method, and he even favored the four-cylinder turbo-petrol’s sound, with the turbo whoosh and exhaust crackle amplified and performed by means of the automobile’s audio system. Its extremely strung 2-litre engine revs actually shortly and pulls relentlessly until its 7,000 rpm redline, nevertheless, it appears like it’s being stretched to serve all it has to supply. Whereas the C 43 did put up a robust combat, on the finish of the day, the M340i’s stronger engine and higher energy and torque-to-weight ratios helped it clock a faster time of 1 minute 56 seconds, half a second faster than the Mercedes-AMG C 43.
“Its setup feels firmer, with a sharper front-end, making the Merc the extra driver-focused.”
Mercedes-AMG C 43 vs BMW M340i: design
Parked beside one another in an identical shade of purple, the Merc is the extra good-looking sedan and comes throughout as a correct head-turner. It sports activities a extremely enticing set of multi-spoke wheels too. The BMW is a slightly acquainted sight because it has been round since 2019, and despite the fact that the M340i bought a refresh not too long ago, its beauty enhancements are restricted and it lacks the novelty issue of the AMG.
On the within too, the AMG’s cabin feels up-to-speed with the instances because of its giant screens, swathes of carbon-fibre-like trims, and sculpted sports activities seats. It has a greater, extra intuitive touchscreen and a way more expansive options record, which incorporates equipment like adjustable dampers, rear axle-steering, panoramic sunroof, Burmester sound system and an electrically operable boot, amongst others. The AMG’s entrance seats are extra snug as compared, and its again seat is roomier and airier too, with its panoramic sunroof flooding the cabin with mild.
The M340i’s twin curved screens are the pièce de résistance of an in any other case bland inside. The touchscreen is fiddly to make use of and the entrance seats are a lot firmer than the AMG’s.
Mercedes-AMG C 43 vs BMW M340i: verdict
Moreover extra assured driving manners, the AMG C 43’s more energizing, extra fashionable outlook makes a stronger impression. So, as a driver’s automobile, it does nicely. And its expansive record of options in addition to high-tech bits like rear-axle steering even justify its Rs 98 lakh asking value, to an extent. The BMW is an efficient Rs 25.10 lakh cheaper, because of native meeting versus the Merc’s CBU-inflated price ticket. Nevertheless it’s not the worth alone that places the BMW forward.
What actually enhances the M340i’s desirability is BMW’s 3.0 six-cylinder turbo-petrol. It’s a gem of an engine that not solely sounds far nicer however can also be an exceptionally robust performer. It offers the automobile faster straight line pace and likewise makes up for its dealing with deficit to the purpose the place the BMW is faster round a race observe too. So in case you’re in search of most bang on your buck, the M340i is the one to have.
Additionally see:
Mercedes-Benz C 300 petrol to exchange C 300d in India
Mercedes India confirms 9 new automobile, SUV launches in 2024